1
Title: Exercises for Field Hockey goalkeepers in the 11-
12 year old category, a proposal
Abstract
Hockey is defined as a sport where two teams face each other in a limited and
standardized field, where the performance of the goalkeeper is decisive, and it is essential
to focus the work from the beginning based on a technical-tactical development according
to the characteristics of the game. . Hence, the objective of this research was: to
determine exercises for defensive actions in field hockey goalkeepers in the 11-12 year
old school category, essential content for modeling training. Three phases were
established for the development of the research: a) analysis of the current state and
treatment of the defensive actions in the goalkeepers of the 11-12 year old school category
in Villa Clara, where an analysis and bibliographic review of various works on the field
hockey theme; b) phase of establishing the exercises, through methodological workshops
with 14 field hockey coaches from the province; c) assessment of the result obtained by
the criteria of specialists, all of which allowed validating the result obtained, constituting
an important element for the work of coaches in this sport.
Keywords: technical-tactical training, field hockey, goalkeepers, initiation
Introduction
Field Hockey is a collective sport of collaboration/opposition, its game is characterized
by individual and group actions and is defined as a sport where two teams face each other
on a limited and standardized field; commonly classified into four demarcations:
goalkeeper, defenders, midfielders and forwards (Sánchez, 2015). Achieving victory will
depend on the individual actions of the players depending on the team (Estellano and
Paniceres, 2017).
His game is very dynamic and creative, with changing actions characterized by a lot of
personal contact that requires high tactical discipline, where periods of different
intensities and high neuromuscular demands alternate with periods of less intensity
(Taylor, Wright, Dischiavi, & Townsend, 2017). ; (Haro, Torres, Casamichana, Romero,
Morencos and Rodas, 2021).
At present, studies on the analysis of the game action in this sport have increased. Various
studies have been carried out regarding the goal action in this sport, however, the existing
scientific literature on field hockey is not as abundant as in other sports games. Both
coaches and researchers emphasize the importance of the goalkeeper's role in the success
of their teams. Most of the research carried out focuses on issues related to the player who
shoots at the goal in the goal action and the penalty corner (Estellano and Paniceres,
2017); (González, Bermúdez, Martínez and Chirosa, 2017).
The most studied parameter within the goal action in Field Hockey is the penalty corner
action, since it is a decisive situation to win a match. Both the winning and losing teams
get more than half of their goals from strategic actions, including penalty corners.
Although it is possible to find studies carried out on game actions, in which the figure of
2
the goalkeeper implicitly intervenes, there are few works aimed at addressing exercises
for the training of this position in particular (Echevarría, Tamayo and Jeffers, 2020).
The field hockey goalkeeper is the base player of a team and enjoys a privileged position
due to the frequency of his interventions and the importance of them. Apart from his stick,
he is the only one who can touch the ball with kicks and gloves inside the goal area. His
behavior especially influences more than any other player in the performance of the team,
which in the final part can influence between 50-70% in the result.
He is in charge of defending his goal preventing the rival team from scoring a goal. He
wears special clothing to protect himself and can use any part of his body to stop the ball
without obstructing play, but he can only do so inside the goal area.
The field hockey goalkeeper plays a fundamental role in the game, he is in charge of
defending against any attack on his team's goal and represents 50% security for himself.
As the last defender, his main concern is the player who has the ball and he has a great
impact on the failure or success of the team, since the main objective of this game is to
score the goal and its function is to avoid it. Therefore, they must have a good preparation
(theoretical, technical-tactical, physical and psychological) to be able to fulfill their
functions within the game (Estellano and Paniceres, 2017); (Vazquez, 2018).
Such characteristics make the goalkeeper the most important player who opposes the goal
action executed by the rivals. However, in the review of the documents issued for the
analysis of the results of the 11-12 year old Field Hockey team of Villa Clara, belonging
to the Comprehensive School of School Sports (EIDE), it is stated that there are
difficulties in the technical actions tactician of the goalkeepers in their defensive
performance, after having obtained or recovered the ball. Remaining this as an important
recommendation to be solved by the coaches and the Provincial Sports Association in the
province.
In another order of analysis, the Comprehensive Field Hockey Athlete Preparation
Program (PIPD) does not contain precise guidelines that enable coaches to develop
technical-tactical defensive actions within the process of preparing school goalkeepers.
Hence, it is so timely to address the issue of actions that lead to the improvement of
technical-tactical defensive actions of goalkeepers, since it is a need derived from the
characteristics of competitive activity to face current challenges (Jiménez, 2011);
Tamayo, Echevarria, and Jeffers, 2019).
As has been previously evidenced, research on the subject has been directed towards the
offensive performance of the game, with defensive actions being more relegated,
fundamentally in the figure of the goalkeeper (Anido, 2014).
Despite the fact that technical-tactical actions constitute a determining direction in the
defensive performance of school goalkeepers in field hockey, there are no guidelines for
their defensive technical-tactical training in this category, which limits coaches in this
regard, as well as the quality of the preparation.
School sport creates the bases for the relay for national teams, to achieve this it is
necessary to develop a whole series of aspects that are implicit from the time the child
enters a sports facility for the first time, until his consolidation as a player (Calero , 2019).
In sports initiation, the assimilation of sports technique for its improvement must be
3
worked very carefully (Castejón, 2002). Therefore, this brings with it the need to dedicate
more time within the annual preparation to the technical-tactical training of players,
especially field hockey goalkeepers (Echevarría, Tamayo and Jeffers, 2020b).
However, the methodology used by coaches when working with goalkeepers in the Villa
Clara province is insufficient (Estellano and Paniceres, 2017); (Tamayo and Echevarría,
2020). In the field hockey learning process, despite having the PIPD, there is no logical
order of the basic fundamentals of teaching according to this specific function, showing
deficiencies in the goalkeepers of the Villa Clara province.
The present study on the figure of the hockey goalkeeper is adjusted to the need to
contribute to the improvement of their performance. Therefore, the objective of the work
was: to determine technical-tactical exercises for defensive actions in field hockey
goalkeepers of the Villa Clara team category 11-12, in correspondence with the specific
characteristics of their performance in the game.
The importance of the research lies in the fact that exercises are proposed for the teaching-
learning of the technical-tactical actions of the Field Hockey goalkeeper 11-12 years old,
based on the real actions of the game that this player faces, to fulfill with his offensive
and defensive performance efficiently in the match.
Materials and methods
To develop the research, a descriptive level and bibliographic review approach was used
on the defensive training of the field hockey goalkeeper in training categories. The
research was developed in three phases, similar to others with similar characteristics. The
first aimed to analyze the situation of the current state of knowledge and treatment of
defensive actions in goalkeepers in the school category, as well as the needs of coaches
in the initiation category (11-12 years) of Field Hockey in the province of Villa Clara,
covered a period between September 2018 to February 2019.
An analysis and bibliographic review of studies that describe the theme of goalkeeper
training were carried out, and these actions have been addressed in a general way. In this
phase, an interview was also conducted with the coaches of the Villa Clara province, with
five open questions, which allowed determining the conception used in the technical-
tactical defensive training of goalkeepers. The analysis of the demands of the game and
the training protocols used by Beach Volleyball coaches at this level in the province was
deepened.
The second phase of the process aimed to establish technical-tactical exercises for
defensive actions in goalkeepers in the 11-12 year old category, which spanned the
months of March - April 2019. An exchange was developed in the form of a workshop,
with the 14 coaches of the province, which includes the two coaches of the EIDE of the
territory, which constitute 100% of the technical force that works in this sport in the
province of Villa Clara. All Graduates in Physical Culture and aged between 25 and 55
years. In addition to having experience as field hockey coaches between 4 and 28 years.
These trainers were used to structure the exercises.
4
Two Methodological Workshops were held within the framework of provincial technical
updates developed by this sport. The first of them was held in the month of March, this
first work session aimed to update current trends in the game of field hockey and analyze
the studies that constitute background. Here the principal investigator served as moderator
and conductor. The purpose was to update the technical force on the subject and current
trends in sports training, so that they could later make accurate assessments for the
establishment of exercises.
The second workshop was held in April 2019, this time the work session aimed to
establish characteristic exercises of the goalkeeper's defensive actions in the 11-12 year
old category. At first, six matches of this category were observed in film projection,
corresponding to the discussions of the two final matches of the 2016, 2017 and 2018
championships. Here the coaches made their notes, identifying the main characteristics
of the game of the goalkeepers, based on the prior knowledge provided by the
antecedents.
In a second moment of the workshop, there is a discussion, debate and exchange with the
coaches on some important issues previously seen. As a result of the work sessions with
the coaches of the province and through the Brainstorming technique, exercises were
established for the defensive technical-tactical training of field hockey goalkeepers in the
11-12 year old category.
In the third phase of the process, a consultation meeting was held with specialists to assess
the result of the exercise proposal. For this, the characteristics or requirements that these
should have, to be used in the investigation, were determined. The concept of specialist
was established as those people who had as a requirement: to have 20 years or more of
experience in the field of Physical Culture and Sports, to hold the scientific category of
Master or Doctor in Physical Culture Sciences, to have worked with Basic initiation field
hockey, or having been linked to it in some way for at least 5 years, having knowledge of
the works that constitute the background of the research and having taught or carried out
research related to the Theory and Methodology of Sports Training .
The group of specialists was made up of 11 members and they were used to obtain
their assessment of the work carried out, in terms of the following aspects:
Formal quality, if the result is appropriate to the characteristics of technical-
tactical training in field hockey for beginners.
Practical utility, its use allows defensive technical-tactical training for field
hockey goalkeepers in the 11-12 year old category in a contextualized manner and
make decisions or establish measures to improve training.
Specificity, if the result is characteristic of the structural and functional actions of
field hockey goalkeeper players in category 11-12.
Possibility of generalization, if they considered that the result has possibilities of
generalization in other similar scenarios.
Results and Discussion
As a result of the first phase of the investigation, it was possible to appreciate, in the
interview carried out with the 14 coaches of the province, that they present deficiencies
in relation to the treatment provided, from the methodological point of view, to the
5
defensive technical-tactical exercises of the field hockey goalkeepers in the 11-12 year
old category.
The fundamental conception used by them lies in conceiving the actions of goalkeepers
in correspondence with the characteristics of competitive activity. On the other hand, with
the bibliographic review it was possible to verify that the works related to the subject do
not address the category of initiation 11-12 years.
In the second moment of the workshop, the following characteristics are summarized: the
goalkeeper needs great reaction speed and reflexes to be able to stop or stop the ball in
advance, damping force to achieve a precise reception, concentration of attention to
coordinate his movements and volume of attention so that it can be accurately represented
where it is easier to clear or see which of his teammates is in the best position to receive
the pass and go on the counterattack, coinciding with Echevarría, Tamayo and Jeffers
(2020a).
In the second phase, technical-tactical defensive exercises were established for field
hockey goalkeepers in the 11-12 year old category, which are shown below.
Exercise 1.
Name: Clearance to free space.
Objectives: Clear a ball thrown by the attacker into free space.
Foundation: Based on a real game situation, the goalkeeper clears a ball thrown by the
attacker into free spaces, trying to keep it as far away as possible.
Methodology: The goalkeepers clear a ball thrown by the attacker to the free space distant
from the opponent, with displacement.
Aspects that are accentuated.
The goalkeeper who clears the ball must:
Move the foot closest to the direction of the hit, to direct the ball towards the target
or free space.
Visual contact with the attacker and the place where he should clear the ball.
Appropriate technique to clear the ball.
It serves as the basis for other exercises and more complex variants in their
execution. With mark, 6-8 repetitions. 6 players participate.
Materials: Ten balls, two teams of goalkeepers, terrain, six obstacles.
Variants: They can be 1 vs 1, 1 vs 2 or in a 3 vs 2 situation.
6
Exercise 2
Name: King goalkeeper.
Objectives: To develop displacement and anticipation skills.
Foundation: Based on a real game situation, it allows more time to react to the actions
of the opponent, allowing the goalkeeper to have more time to decide the action variable
in the game situation.
Methodology: Two goalkeepers are separated by a distance of 6 meters, a ball is placed
between them, both are placed in basic position at the voice of the coach, they run to take
the ball and the one who does not take it must touch the partner's back before he passes
the catcher's starting line. It is repeated several times.
Materials: Ten balls, two teams of goalkeepers, terrain, six obstacles.
Exercise 3
Name: Varied clearance.
Objectives: To develop displacement and anticipation skills.
Foundation: Based on a real game situation, the goalkeeper clears a ball thrown by the
attacker into empty space or sidelines.
Methodology: A specialized obstacle is placed longitudinally behind the penalty-stroke
point, the goalkeeper is placed in the goal, the coach is placed on the opposite side
separated by one meter. When the goalkeeper is ready, the coach begins to throw balls
against the obstacle, the balls take effect in such a way that the goalkeeper must apply an
appropriate clearance technique according to the type of ball. Batches of 10 balls are
made.
Materials: Ten balls, two teams of goalkeepers, terrain, six obstacles.
Exercise 4
Name: Directed balls.
Objectives: To develop displacement and anticipation skills.
7
Foundation: Based on a real game situation, the goalkeeper develops the ability to guide
clearances in different game situations, directing them in directions that do not complicate
the defensive tactical situation of the team.
Methodology: The goalkeeper stands at the goal, two mini goals are placed in the area
where the clearance should be directed, balls are hit slowly from the edge of the area and
as soon as it is hit, the goalkeeper is told where to direct the ball. , so you will have to
choose the right clearance technique. The number of goals scored by the goalkeeper is
counted and a competition between goalkeepers is established. Do not throw more than
10 balls at a time.
Materials: Ten balls, two teams of goalkeepers, terrain, six obstacles.
Exercise 5
Name: Displacement and stops.
Objectives: To develop displacement and anticipation skills.
Foundation: Based on a real game situation, it allows the development of anticipation
skills in the execution of shot stops on goal from variable conditions.
Methodology: A mark is made with plaster or tape on the posts between the squad and
the height of the goalkeepers shoulders. The goalkeeper stands in the center of the goal
and at the voice of the coach moves slowly touching the mark on the tape with the glove
of the corresponding hand, quickly returning to the other side to stop a ball that the coach
throws with his hand in the middle , low and maximum height according to its
possibilities. Return to the center and perform on the opposite side. Do not use series of
more than 8 balls.
Materials: Ten balls, two teams of goalkeepers, terrain, six obstacles.
Form of qualification of the exercises
Good (B): If you perform the technical execution with up to 2 errors.
Regular (R): If you perform the technical execution with 3 or 4 errors.
Bad (M): If you perform the technical execution with more than 4 errors
In the third phase, as a result of the evaluation by the specialists, 100% consider that the
result shows a high formal quality of its structure, since they include the main movements
and stops of the goalkeeper during the action and can be used in their technical-tactical
training, giving it a modeled character.
They consider that the result has great practical utility, because it can provide relevant
information for coaches based on the characteristics of the actions of these players. Its
use will allow establishing reference values for the technical-tactical training of
goalkeepers at this competitive level.
8
They valued that the result has specificity, since its structuring is based on the functional
analysis of the field hockey game in the school category, in addition to considering the
internal logic and the characteristics of the game in the 11-12 year old category. 100% of
the specialists also considered that this result fulfills the purposes for which it was
conceived and that it could contribute to the development of technical-tactical skills in
goalkeepers.
Finally they stated that, if it has great possibilities of generalization, because the
conception that supports the result can be applied in other territories, contexts and other
categories. In addition, it is an important element that should contribute to enrich the
conceptions of the PIPD, as the governing document of this sport in Cuba.
In the same way, all (100%) agreed that it contributes to the solution of the insufficiencies
detected, in the treatment of the actions of the goalkeepers in the defense in the game of
Field Hockey, since it allows, on the one hand, , perfect your game on defense; as well as
developing goalkeeping skills to play with the feet, the stick and support the ball carrier
near the 14.63 meter area.
It was taken into account for the structuring of the exercises, that in the action of the game
there is a high number of structural elements such as teammates, adversaries, mobile and
spatial goals to defend and/or attack. All of which demands that the players are subjected
to constant decision-making, to make their game actions effective, in an environment of
constant uncertainty, which may be regarding the information coming from the physical
medium, and/or regarding the interaction with teammates and/or opponents.
In correspondence with the approaches of other authors such as Sánchez (2015) and
Matías (2018), taking these elements into account by coaches will allow them to choose
each exercise and each activity with full knowledge of the facts, depending on the
achievement of their objectives. proposed. Generally, the works that address this topic
focus on studying the goalkeeper's action from the perspective of the number of goals
conceded depending on the shooting zone, the place where the shot enters and the
techniques used by the goalkeeper.
The exercises designed to treat the defensive actions of goalkeepers enrich the scarce
specialized bibliography that exists on the subject in question, which benefits not only the
level of knowledge of the coaches, but also, to a certain extent, allows them to the players,
prepare theoretically to better study the game that takes place in this area of the Field
Hockey field, so important and decisive in the victory or defeat of the match.
Conclusions
The state of the defensive technical-tactical actions of the field hockey goalkeepers,
school category 11-12 of the EIDE of Villa Clara, manifests with deficiencies in the
conception of the exercises for the training of the goalkeepers' defensive technical-tactical
actions. 11-12 years.
The proposal of technical-tactical exercises for the defensive actions of the goalkeepers
in the aforementioned category was determined on the basis of real game situations and
the defensive functional demands of the field hockey goalkeeper today. Its foundation
and structure favor the development of technical-tactical defense actions of goalkeepers
at this level in correspondence with the specific characteristics of their performance in
the game.
9
The conception of the proposal of exercises for the treatment of the technical-tactical
actions of the defense in the goalkeepers, has a high practical utility and represents a
methodological contribution to the problem that is addressed, according to the criteria
expressed by the specialists.
References
Anido Gonzalez, Y.R. (2014). Exercises to improve the technical actions of hockey
goalkeepers. (Diploma work). UCCFD, Faculty of Physical Culture of Holguín.
Calero, S. (2019). Fundamentals of optimized sports training. Department of Human and
Social Sciences. Postgraduate Course of the Master in Sports Training. XIII
Promotion (pp. 2-76). Quito: University of the Armed Forces ESPE.
https://www.researchgate.net/publicationhttp://podium.upr.edu.cu/index.php/pod
ium/article/view/1128/320053667_Fundamentos_del_entrenamiento_optimizado
_How_to_achieve_a_high_sports_performance_in_the_shortest_time_possible
Castejon Oliva, F.J. (2002). Experts and novices in the teaching-learning process and its
involvement in sports initiation. Motor Skill, 20, 13-27.
https://www.colefandalucia.com/_files/ugd/28d333_932ab6f1fd7d407483778e2
6f53f5da5.pdf
Echevarría Ramírez, O., Tamayo Rodríguez, Y. S., and Jeffers Duarte, B. (2020a).
Approach to the particularities of sports initiation and the selection of sports talent.
Didasc@lia: Didactics and Education. 11(3), 259-270.
https://revistas.ult.edu.cu/index.php/didascalia/article/view/1004/1020
Echevarría Ramírez, O., Tamayo Rodríguez, Y. S., and Jeffers Duarte, B. (2020b). The
apprehension in the teaching-learning process of Field Hockey in the basic sports
initiation. FESC World, 10(S1), 60-67.
https://www.fesc.edu.co/Revistas/OJS/index.php/mundofesc/article/view/397/47
1
Estellano, M. and Paniceres, E. (2017). Methodology used in the teaching of the short
corner in female field hockey training categories. A study focused on a female
hockey sub14. (Thesis). IUACJ, Montevideo.
González, A., Bermúdez, S. G., Martínez, I., and Chirosa, L. J. (2017). Efficiency of
goalkeepers in the ODESUR Games and Pan American Handball Championship
in 2014. Notes. Physical Education and Sports, 4, 95-105. https://revista-
10
apunts.com/eficacia-de-los-goalkeepers-en-los-juegos-odesur-y-campeonato-
panamericano-de-handball-en-2014/
Haro, X., Torres, L., Casamichana, D., Romero-Moraleda, B., Morencos, E., & Rodas,
G. (2021). International Competition Kinematic Demands in Male Field Hockey.
notes Physical Education and Sports, 143, 90-99.
https://doi.org/10.5672/apunts.2014-0983.es.(2021/1).143.10
Jimenez Jimenez, F. (2011). Structural analysis of teaching situations in team sports.
Motor Action. (6). 39-57.
Sánchez Alarcos Díaz Pintado, J. V. (2015). Pre index that determines the anticipation of
the field hockey goalie before a backhand hit. (Doctoral thesis). University of
Valencia. Spain.
Tamayo Rodríguez, Y. S., and Echevarría Ramírez, O. (2020). Modeling and the systems
approach in the field hockey teaching-learning process from the developer
learning approach: modeling and the systems approach in the teaching-learning
process. Didasc@lia Magazine: Didactics and Education. 11(2), 246-256.
https://revistas.ult.edu.cu/index.php/didascalia/article/view/964/961
Tamayo Rodríguez, Y. S., Echevarría Ramírez, O., and Jeffers Duarte, B. (2019). A
developer learning approach in the sports initiation of field hockey (s/c) in the
base. In Arboleda Aparicio, J. C. (Eds.), Research Contextualization in Education,
Physical Culture and Sport IV Education and Pedagogy 2019. REDIPE
(95857440), New York Cal., 16-25.
Taylor, J.B., Wright, A.A., Dischiavi, & Townsend, M.A. (2017). Activity Demands
During Multi-Directional Team Sports: A Systematic Review. Sports Medicine,
47, 25332551. DOI 10.1007/s40279-017-0772-5
Vazquez, M. (2018). Analysis of the effectiveness of defensive actions of female field
hockey goalkeepers, in the U-21 Pan American Championship in 2016. (Final
degree project). University Institute Christian Youth Association.